Skip to content

13F-HR filed by Symmetry Partners, LLC

Symmetry Partners, LLC filed this 13F-HR for the quarter ended 2020-03-31, filed 2020-05-15, with 278 holding rows worth $450,514,000.

Accession
0001697493-20-000004
Filed
2020-05-15
Accepted by EDGAR
acceptance time not in the bulk data set
Ingested
Source
SEC quarterly data set

Original filing

13F report for Q1 2020

A holdings report, 279 entries on the cover page, a total value of $450,514,000 stated on the cover page (in dollars after the unit check, H1), rows summing to $450,514,000 with VALUE read as thousands by filing date, 13F file number 028-17760. The quarter's positions are built on this report. The resolved quarter.

The information table after summing rows of one CUSIP and put or call (H4), with the CUSIP and issuer name as filed. Values in dollars after the unit check (method).

Issuer as filedCUSIPClassAmountValueValue read asType
Vanguard Total Bond Market ETF921937835SHS494,695$42,223,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard Total International Bond Index Fund ETF92203J407SHS688,372$38,728,000thousands by filing date
VTI922908769COM194,858$25,120,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard Small-Cap Value ETF922908611SHS207,848$18,458,000thousands by filing date
iShares MSCI USA Momentum Factor ETF46432F396SHS146,557$15,605,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard Value ETF922908744SHS164,332$14,637,000thousands by filing date
iShares MSCI EAFE Value ETF464288877SHS404,003$14,419,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard FTSE Developed Markets ETF921943858SHS405,463$13,518,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard FTSE All-World ex-US Small-Cap ETF922042718SHS168,682$13,199,000thousands by filing date
Microsoft Corp594918104COM82,045$12,939,000thousands by filing date
Apple Inc037833100COM46,971$11,944,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464288414NATIONAL MUN ETF94,892$10,724,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard Mid-Cap Value ETF922908512SHS131,553$10,694,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard Short-Term Bond ETF921937827SHS127,731$10,497,000thousands by filing date
VWO922042858SHS250,619$8,409,000thousands by filing date
SPDR SER TR78468R622BLOOMBERG HIGH Y74,787$7,086,000thousands by filing date
ABRDN PRECIOUS METALS BASKET003263100PHYSCL PRECS MET76,993$5,782,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464288687COM172,087$5,479,000thousands by filing date
VANGUARD SCOTTSDALE FDS92206C409COM58,149$4,600,000thousands by filing date
Walmart Inc.931142103COM33,830$3,844,000thousands by filing date
VANGUARD SCOTTSDALE FDS92206C771SHS67,915$3,701,000thousands by filing date
META PLATFORMS INC CL A30303M102COM21,269$3,548,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard Real Estate922908553SHS49,525$3,460,000thousands by filing date
JPMorgan Chase & Co46625H100COM37,912$3,413,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464288281JPMORGAN USD EMG34,985$3,383,000thousands by filing date
Utilities Select Sector SPDR Fund81369Y886SHS60,147$3,333,000thousands by filing date
Technology Select Sector SPDR Fund81369Y803SHS41,162$3,308,000thousands by filing date
SPDR SERIES TRUST78468R408ST TERM HIGH ETF136,398$3,214,000thousands by filing date
TAIWAN SEMICONDUCTOR MFG874039100SPONSORED ADS66,973$3,201,000thousands by filing date
iShares MSCI USA Min Vol Factor ETF46429B697SHS56,738$3,064,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES MSCI USA QUALITY FACTOR ETF46432F339ETF37,228$3,017,000thousands by filing date
Procter & Gamble Co742718109COM27,248$2,997,000thousands by filing date
VANGUARD MALVERN FDS922020805SHS59,180$2,883,000thousands by filing date
AT&T Inc00206R102COM80,463$2,346,000thousands by filing date
Bank of America Corp060505104COM109,950$2,334,000thousands by filing date
SPDR SERIES TRUST78468R739ST NUVE TERM ETF45,779$2,239,000thousands by filing date
iShares MSCI Frontier 100464286145cs92,627$1,978,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES MSCI EAFE MIN VOL FACTOR ETF46429B689ETF30,652$1,902,000thousands by filing date
VANGUARD INTL EQUITY INDEX F922042676COM43,518$1,867,000thousands by filing date
Costco Wholesale Corporation22160K105COM6,246$1,781,000thousands by filing date
Intel Corp458140100COM31,254$1,692,000thousands by filing date
SELECT SECTOR SPDR TR81369Y308STATE STREET CON29,593$1,612,000thousands by filing date
Health Care Select Sector SPDR Fund81369Y209SHS17,684$1,567,000thousands by filing date
Lockheed Martin Corporation539830109COM4,088$1,386,000thousands by filing date
Citigroup Inc.172967424COM30,020$1,264,000thousands by filing date
Danaher Corporation235851102COM8,954$1,240,000thousands by filing date
Medtronic PlcG5960L103COM11,991$1,081,000thousands by filing date
Bristol-Myers Squibb Company110122108COM18,937$1,056,000thousands by filing date
NVIDIA Corp67066G104COM3,988$1,051,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES INC464286533MSCI EMERG MRKT22,063$1,035,000thousands by filing date
Accenture Plc Class AG1151C101COM6,332$1,034,000thousands by filing date
TARGET CORP COM87612E106Stock10,926$1,016,000thousands by filing date
Qualcomm Incorporated747525103COM14,864$1,006,000thousands by filing date
DOLLAR GEN CORP COM256677105Stock6,580$994,000thousands by filing date
Home Depot, Inc437076102COM5,006$935,000thousands by filing date
LAM RESEARCH CORP512807108COM3,856$925,000thousands by filing date
Micron Technology,Inc.595112103COM20,835$876,000thousands by filing date
NORTHROP GRUMMAN CORP COM666807102Stock2,842$860,000thousands by filing date
Applied Materials,Inc.038222105COM18,371$842,000thousands by filing date
ZOETIS INC CL A98978V103Stock7,129$839,000thousands by filing date
HUMANA INC COM444859102Stock2,637$828,000thousands by filing date
LAUDER ESTEE COS INC CL A518439104Stock5,182$826,000thousands by filing date
AIR PRODS & CHEMS INC009158106COM4,094$817,000thousands by filing date
CABLE ONE INC12685J105COM486$799,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES SHORT-TERM NATIONAL MUNI BOND ETF464288158ETF7,171$763,000thousands by filing date
Starbucks Corporation855244109COM11,518$757,000thousands by filing date
VANGUARD INDEX FDS922908637LARGE CAP ETF6,186$733,000thousands by filing date
TJX Companies Inc872540109COM14,956$715,000thousands by filing date
USBANCORPDEL902973304COM NEW19,509$672,000thousands by filing date
Chubb LimitedH1467J104COM6,011$671,000thousands by filing date
PNC FINL SVCS GROUP INC COM693475105Stock6,970$667,000thousands by filing date
Eaton Corp. PlcG29183103COM8,559$665,000thousands by filing date
LULULEMON ATHLETICA INC550021109COM3,451$654,000thousands by filing date
EDWARDS LIFESCIENCES CORP COM28176E108Stock3,425$646,000thousands by filing date
AUTOZONE INC COM053332102Stock755$639,000thousands by filing date
MATCH GROUP INC57665R106COM9,477$626,000thousands by filing date
TRANE TECHNOLOGIES PLC SHSG8994E103Stock7,501$618,000thousands by filing date
TERADYNE INC COM880770102Stock11,273$611,000thousands by filing date
BOOZ ALLEN HAMILTON HLDG CORP CL A099502106Stock8,902$611,000thousands by filing date
Visa Inc92826C839COM3,746$604,000thousands by filing date
SHERWIN WILLIAMS CO824348106COM1,280$588,000thousands by filing date
CUMMINS INC COM231021106Stock4,262$577,000thousands by filing date
MARKETAXESS HLDGS INC57060D108COM1,734$577,000thousands by filing date
KEYSIGHT TECHNOLOGIES INC COM49338L103Stock6,742$564,000thousands by filing date
HERSHEY CO COM427866108Stock4,257$564,000thousands by filing date
LEIDOS HOLDINGS INC COM525327102Stock6,095$559,000thousands by filing date
GARMIN LTD SHSH2906T109Stock7,408$555,000thousands by filing date
UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORP913017109COM5,886$555,000thousands by filing date
HORIZON THERAPEUTICS PLCG46188101SHS18,669$553,000thousands by filing date
CVS Health Corporation126650100COM9,293$551,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464287457COM6,229$540,000thousands by filing date
CDW CORP COM12514G108Stock5,721$534,000thousands by filing date
CADENCE DESIGN SYSTEM INC COM127387108Stock8,041$531,000thousands by filing date
SCOTTS MIRACLE-GRO CO810186106CL A5,169$529,000thousands by filing date
BERKLEY W R CORP COM084423102Stock9,928$518,000thousands by filing date
DOVER CORP COM260003108Stock6,135$515,000thousands by filing date
THE CAMPBELLS COMPANY COM134429109Stock11,126$514,000thousands by filing date
TYSON FOODS INC CL A902494103Stock8,839$512,000thousands by filing date
NVR INC COM62944T105Stock199$511,000thousands by filing date
GENERAL MILLS INC COM370334104Stock9,615$507,000thousands by filing date
Southern Company842587107COM9,352$506,000thousands by filing date
MASCO CORP574599106COM14,613$505,000thousands by filing date
Goldman Sachs Group,Inc.38141G104COM3,217$497,000thousands by filing date
DAVITA INC COM23918K108Stock6,375$485,000thousands by filing date
ALLSTATE CORP COM020002101Stock5,257$482,000thousands by filing date
AVALARA INC05338G106COM6,458$482,000thousands by filing date
CONAGRA FOODS INC205887102COM16,324$479,000thousands by filing date
TELEDYNE TECHNOLOGIES INC COM879360105Stock1,612$479,000thousands by filing date
MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS INC COM NEW620076307Stock3,583$476,000thousands by filing date
OLD DOMINION FREIGHT LINE INC COM679580100Stock3,623$476,000thousands by filing date
GLOBAL PMTS INC37940X102COM3,258$470,000thousands by filing date
REPUBLIC SVCS INC COM760759100Stock6,203$466,000thousands by filing date
KLA CORP482480100COM3,180$457,000thousands by filing date
COSTAR GROUP INC COM22160N109Stock775$455,000thousands by filing date
SKYWORKS SOLUTIONS INC COM83088M102Stock5,087$455,000thousands by filing date
CROWN HLDGS INC COM228368106Stock7,838$455,000thousands by filing date
PULTE GROUP INC COM745867101Stock20,360$454,000thousands by filing date
AON PLCG0408V102SHS CL A2,746$453,000thousands by filing date
AFLAC INC COM001055102Stock13,099$449,000thousands by filing date
QORVO INC COM74736K101Stock5,542$447,000thousands by filing date
EVEREST GROUP LTD COMG3223R108Stock2,310$445,000thousands by filing date
PRICE T ROWE GROUP INC COM74144T108Stock4,559$445,000thousands by filing date
RELIANCE INC759509102COM5,069$444,000thousands by filing date
JACOBS ENGINEERING GROUP INC469814107COM5,595$444,000thousands by filing date
ARCH CAP GROUP LTD ORDG0450A105Stock15,405$438,000thousands by filing date
D R HORTON INC COM23331A109Stock12,822$436,000thousands by filing date
BEST BUY INC COM086516101Stock7,626$435,000thousands by filing date
AKAMAI TECHNOLOGIES INC COM00971T101Stock4,740$434,000thousands by filing date
TRAVELERS COMPANIES INC COM89417E109Stock4,356$433,000thousands by filing date
ZEBRA TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION CL A989207105Stock2,358$433,000thousands by filing date
ENTEGRIS INC COM29362U104Stock9,565$428,000thousands by filing date
CINCINNATI FINL CORP COM172062101Stock5,657$427,000thousands by filing date
Progressive Corporation743315103COM5,771$426,000thousands by filing date
COPART INC COM217204106Stock6,200$425,000thousands by filing date
SYNOPSYS INC COM871607107Stock3,295$424,000thousands by filing date
CARLISLE COS INC COM142339100Stock3,360$421,000thousands by filing date
Marsh & McLennan Companies,Inc.571748102COM4,862$420,000thousands by filing date
MARTIN MARIETTA MATLS INC COM573284106Stock2,211$418,000thousands by filing date
TRUIST FINL CORP COM89832Q109Stock13,554$418,000thousands by filing date
MEDICAL PROPERTIES TRUST INC COM58463J304REIT24,185$418,000thousands by filing date
INGERSOLL RAND INC COM45687V106Stock16,772$416,000thousands by filing date
Honeywell Technologies438516106COM3,104$415,000thousands by filing date
CASEYS GEN STORES INC147528103COM3,131$415,000thousands by filing date
PACCAR INC COM693718108Stock6,783$415,000thousands by filing date
Coca-Cola Company191216100COM9,360$414,000thousands by filing date
BURLINGTON STORES INC COM122017106Stock2,605$413,000thousands by filing date
ALLEGHANY CORP DEL017175100COM747$413,000thousands by filing date
VERISK ANALYTICS INC COM92345Y106Stock2,947$411,000thousands by filing date
FASTENAL CO COM311900104Stock13,069$408,000thousands by filing date
ILLINOIS TOOL WKS INC452308109COM2,862$407,000thousands by filing date
JOHNSON CTLS INTL PLC SHSG51502105Stock14,976$404,000thousands by filing date
CHEMED CORP NEW16359R103COM933$404,000thousands by filing date
BROOKFIELD ASSET MANAGEMENT IN112585104CL A LTD VT SH9,211$404,000thousands by filing date
CACI INTL INC CL A127190304Stock1,906$402,000thousands by filing date
SKECHERS U S A INC830566105CL A16,883$401,000thousands by filing date
FAIR ISAAC CORP COM303250104Stock1,296$399,000thousands by filing date
CINTAS CORP COM172908105Stock2,301$399,000thousands by filing date
AMERIPRISE FINL INC COM03076C106Stock3,815$391,000thousands by filing date
AGCO CORP001084102COM8,271$391,000thousands by filing date
EPAM SYS INC COM29414B104Stock2,100$390,000thousands by filing date
LENNAR CORP CL A526057104Stock10,150$388,000thousands by filing date
Philip Morris International Inc.718172109COM5,227$381,000thousands by filing date
FERRARI N VN3167Y103COM2,490$380,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES 1-5 YEAR INVESTMENT GRADE CORPORATE BOND ETF464288646ETF7,239$379,000thousands by filing date
GENTEX CORP COM371901109Stock16,941$376,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard Small-Cap ETF922908751SHS3,236$375,000thousands by filing date
POOL CORP COM73278L105Stock1,894$373,000thousands by filing date
METLIFE INC COM59156R108Stock12,126$371,000thousands by filing date
MANULIFE FINL CORP56501R106COM29,699$369,000thousands by filing date
BALL CORP058498106COM5,646$365,000thousands by filing date
QUEST DIAGNOSTICS INC COM74834L100Stock4,532$364,000thousands by filing date
BLACKROCK INC CL A COM09247X101COM820$361,000thousands by filing date
ANSYS INC COM03662Q105COM1,551$361,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard Intermediate-Term Bond ETF921937819SHS4,027$360,000thousands by filing date
ALLEGION PLCG0176J109ORD SHS3,916$360,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard FTSE Europe ETF922042874SHS8,250$357,000thousands by filing date
Waste Management, Inc.94106L109COM3,838$355,000thousands by filing date
UNITED RENTALS INC COM911363109Stock3,419$352,000thousands by filing date
RENAISSANCERE HLDGS LTD COMG7496G103Stock2,352$351,000thousands by filing date
JABIL INC COM466313103Stock14,235$350,000thousands by filing date
ARMSTRONG WORLD INDS INC NEW04247X102COM4,387$348,000thousands by filing date
HUBBELL INC COM443510607Stock3,001$344,000thousands by filing date
L3HARRIS TECHNOLOGIES INC COM502431109Stock1,871$337,000thousands by filing date
KIMBERLY-CLARK CORP COM494368103Stock2,631$336,000thousands by filing date
American Express Company025816109COM3,870$331,000thousands by filing date
UNIVERSAL HLTH SVCS INC CL B913903100Stock3,306$328,000thousands by filing date
FIDELITY NATIONAL FINANCIAL31620R303FNF GROUP COM13,126$327,000thousands by filing date
MGIC INVT CORP WIS COM552848103Stock51,380$326,000thousands by filing date
HEICO CORP NEW COM422806109Stock4,361$325,000thousands by filing date
OSHKOSH CORP COM688239201Stock5,058$325,000thousands by filing date
WESTERN UN CO COM959802109Stock17,931$325,000thousands by filing date
XEROX HOLDINGS CORP98421M106COM NEW17,017$322,000thousands by filing date
Union Pacific Corporation907818108COM2,256$318,000thousands by filing date
ERIE INDTY CO CL A29530P102Stock2,143$318,000thousands by filing date
WEST PHARMACEUTICAL SVSC INC COM955306105Stock2,079$317,000thousands by filing date
ASSURANT INC COM04621X108Stock3,027$315,000thousands by filing date
UNIVERSAL DISPLAY CORP91347P105COM2,394$315,000thousands by filing date
ITT INC COM45073V108Stock6,866$311,000thousands by filing date
NAVIENT CORPORATION COM63938C108Stock40,734$309,000thousands by filing date
FIRST AMERN FINL CORP31847R102COM7,275$309,000thousands by filing date
PILGRIMS PRIDE CORP COM72147K108Stock16,988$308,000thousands by filing date
TD SYNNEX CORPORATION COM87162W100Stock4,193$307,000thousands by filing date
Morgan Stanley617446448COM8,999$306,000thousands by filing date
DELTA AIR LINES INC COM NEW247361702Stock10,681$305,000thousands by filing date
Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc.883556102COM1,070$303,000thousands by filing date
OWENS CORNING NEW690742101COM7,811$303,000thousands by filing date
FLEETCOR TECHNOLOGIES INC339041105COM1,626$303,000thousands by filing date
AUTONATION INC COM05329W102Stock10,663$299,000thousands by filing date
SOMNIGROUP INTERNATIONAL INC COM88023U101Stock6,826$298,000thousands by filing date
SUN LIFE FINANCIAL INC. COM866796105Stock9,290$295,000thousands by filing date
LKQ CORP COM501889208Stock14,354$294,000thousands by filing date
AbbVie,Inc.00287Y109COM3,852$293,000thousands by filing date
NextEra Energy,Inc.65339F101COM1,216$293,000thousands by filing date
AXIS CAP HLDGS LTD SHSG0692U109Stock7,584$293,000thousands by filing date
WOODWARD INC COM980745103Stock4,929$293,000thousands by filing date
KANSAS CITY SOUTHERN485170302COM NEW2,267$288,000thousands by filing date
ALLY FINL INC COM02005N100Stock19,917$287,000thousands by filing date
HANOVER INS GROUP INC COM410867105Stock3,165$287,000thousands by filing date
FIFTH THIRD BANCORP COM316773100Stock19,022$283,000thousands by filing date
SYNCHRONYFINL87165B103STOK17,500$282,000thousands by filing date
FORTUNE BRANDS INNOVATIONS INC COM34964C106Stock6,473$280,000thousands by filing date
WILLIAMS SONOMA INC COM969904101Stock6,587$280,000thousands by filing date
ECOLAB INC COM278865100Stock1,786$278,000thousands by filing date
BIO RAD LABS INC090572207CL A793$278,000thousands by filing date
GEN DIGITAL INC COM668771108Stock14,533$272,000thousands by filing date
DISCOVER FINL SVCS254709108COM7,634$272,000thousands by filing date
HENRY JACK & ASSOC INC426281101COM1,755$272,000thousands by filing date
PPG INDS INC COM693506107Stock3,192$267,000thousands by filing date
PAYCOMSOFTWAREINC70432V102STOK1,305$264,000thousands by filing date
CELANESE CORP DEL COM150870103Stock3,582$263,000thousands by filing date
ASSURED GUARANTY LTD COMG0585R106Stock10,089$260,000thousands by filing date
Amgen Inc.031162100COM1,230$249,000thousands by filing date
GRAPHIC PACKAGING HLDG CO COM388689101Stock20,443$249,000thousands by filing date
HARTFORD INSURANCE GROUP INC COM416515104Stock7,054$249,000thousands by filing date
ARCONIC INC03965L100COM15,510$249,000thousands by filing date
CITIZENS FINL GROUP INC COM174610105Stock12,950$244,000thousands by filing date
POPULAR INC733174700COM NEW6,976$244,000thousands by filing date
STERIS PLC SHS USDG8473T100Stock1,723$241,000thousands by filing date
NUANCE COMMUNICATIONS INC67020Y100COM14,384$241,000thousands by filing date
RESMED INC COM761152107Stock1,626$239,000thousands by filing date
DENTSPLY SIRONA INC24906P109COM6,157$239,000thousands by filing date
BROADRIDGE FINL SOLUTIONS INC COM11133T103Stock2,509$238,000thousands by filing date
International Business Machines Corporation459200101COM2,130$236,000thousands by filing date
CERNER CORP156782104COM3,730$235,000thousands by filing date
MANPOWERGROUP INC WIS COM56418H100Stock4,409$234,000thousands by filing date
Mondelez International,Inc. Class A609207105COM4,638$232,000thousands by filing date
STATE STR CORP COM857477103Stock4,364$232,000thousands by filing date
CBRE GROUP INC CL A12504L109Stock6,080$229,000thousands by filing date
SYSCOCORP871829107COM4,995$228,000thousands by filing date
GENPACT LIMITED SHSG3922B107Stock7,801$228,000thousands by filing date
MASIMO CORP COM574795100Stock1,267$224,000thousands by filing date
BRUKER CORP116794108COM6,226$223,000thousands by filing date
OREILLY AUTOMOTIVE INC COM67103H107Stock739$222,000thousands by filing date
OLD REP INTL CORP COM680223104Stock14,539$222,000thousands by filing date
SONOCO PRODS CO835495102COM4,799$222,000thousands by filing date
UBIQUITI INC90353W103COM1,567$222,000thousands by filing date
Anglogold Ashanti Plc035128206Common13,374$222,000thousands by filing date
MANHATTAN ASSOCIATES INC COM562750109Stock4,439$221,000thousands by filing date
ATMOS ENERGY CORP COM049560105Stock2,193$218,000thousands by filing date
AMERICAN INTL GROUP INC COM NEW026874784Stock8,976$218,000thousands by filing date
ARAMARK COM03852U106Stock10,890$217,000thousands by filing date
PHILLIPS 66 COM718546104Stock3,950$212,000thousands by filing date
PRUDENTIAL FINL INC COM744320102Stock3,991$208,000thousands by filing date
CHURCH & DWIGHT CO INC COM171340102Stock3,230$207,000thousands by filing date
SOUTHWESTAIRLSCO844741108STOK5,758$205,000thousands by filing date
HUNTINGTON BANCSHARES INC COM446150104Stock24,898$204,000thousands by filing date
AMERICA MOVIL SA DE CV-ADR02364W105SPON ADR L SHS17,135$202,000thousands by filing date
KEYCORP COM493267108Stock18,019$187,000thousands by filing date
NEW YORK COMMUNITY BANCORP649445103COM19,407$182,000thousands by filing date
REGIONS FINANCIAL CORP NEW COM7591EP100Stock17,956$161,000thousands by filing date
COMPANHIA DE SANEAMENTO BASICO SPONSORED ADR20441A102ADR20,683$153,000thousands by filing date
TIM PARTICIPACOES S A88706P205SPONSORED ADR11,426$139,000thousands by filing date
VALE S A91912E105SPONSORED ADS15,673$130,000thousands by filing date
GOLD FIELDS LTD SPONSORED ADR38059T106ADR25,933$123,000thousands by filing date
COTY INC222070203COM CL A23,244$120,000thousands by filing date
KIMCO REALTY CORP COM49446R109REIT11,448$111,000thousands by filing date
KINROSS GOLD CORP496902404COM24,772$98,000thousands by filing date
ZYNGA INC.98986T108CL A10,517$72,000thousands by filing date

Amendment chain

FilingRoleFiledAcceptedIngested
13F-HR 0001697493-20-000004this filing2020-05-15acceptance time not in the bulk data set