Skip to content

13F-HR filed by MURPHY CAPITAL MANAGEMENT INC

MURPHY CAPITAL MANAGEMENT INC filed this 13F-HR for the quarter ended 2017-03-31, filed 2017-04-11, with 273 holding rows worth $672,684,000.

Accession
0001056515-17-000004
Filed
2017-04-11
Accepted by EDGAR
acceptance time not in the bulk data set
Ingested
Source
SEC quarterly data set

Original filing

13F report for Q1 2017

A holdings report, 273 entries on the cover page, a total value of $672,684,000 stated on the cover page (in dollars after the unit check, H1), rows summing to $672,548,000 with VALUE read as thousands by filing date, 13F file number 028-03913. The quarter's positions are built on this report. The resolved quarter.

The information table after summing rows of one CUSIP and put or call (H4), with the CUSIP and issuer name as filed. Values in dollars after the unit check (method).

Issuer as filedCUSIPClassAmountValueValue read asType
Apple Inc037833100COM178,653$25,665,000thousands by filing date
PIONEER NATURAL RESOURCES CO723787107COM110,100$20,503,000thousands by filing date
PowerShares QQQ Trust Unit Ser73935A104COM126,881$16,796,000thousands by filing date
SPY78462F103SHS68,389$16,122,000thousands by filing date
Health Care Select Sector SPDR Fund81369Y209SHS200,937$14,941,000thousands by filing date
Home Depot, Inc437076102COM96,289$14,138,000thousands by filing date
Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund81369Y605SHS580,897$13,784,000thousands by filing date
Johnson & Johnson478160104COM104,342$12,995,000thousands by filing date
Walt Disney Co254687106COM108,957$12,354,000thousands by filing date
VGT92204A702SHS88,075$11,945,000thousands by filing date
Verizon Communications Inc92343V104COM241,668$11,781,000thousands by filing date
Altria Group Inc02209S103COM160,625$11,471,000thousands by filing date
EXXON MOBIL CORP30231G102COM138,747$11,378,000thousands by filing date
3M CO COM88579Y101Stock59,270$11,340,000thousands by filing date
FIRST TR EXCHANGE-TRADED FD33733E302DJ INTERNT IDX128,517$11,314,000thousands by filing date
META PLATFORMS INC CL A30303M102COM74,278$10,551,000thousands by filing date
UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORP913017109COM87,657$9,836,000thousands by filing date
JPMorgan Chase & Co46625H100COM108,448$9,526,000thousands by filing date
Boeing Company097023105COM51,628$9,130,000thousands by filing date
STATE STR SPDR DOW JONES IND78467X109UT SER 143,571$8,990,000thousands by filing date
Procter & Gamble Co742718109COM96,712$8,689,000thousands by filing date
Amazon.com, Inc023135106COM9,716$8,613,000thousands by filing date
AT&T Inc00206R102COM184,777$7,677,000thousands by filing date
SELECT SECTOR SPDR TR81369Y704INDL116,999$7,611,000thousands by filing date
Berkshire Hathaway Inc084670702COM45,162$7,527,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464287762US HLTHCARE ETF47,427$7,384,000thousands by filing date
International Business Machines Corporation459200101COM42,338$7,372,000thousands by filing date
Visa Inc92826C839COM80,079$7,116,000thousands by filing date
McDonalds Corporation580135101COM53,135$6,886,000thousands by filing date
GENERAL ELEC CO369604103COM230,502$6,868,000thousands by filing date
PepsiCo,Inc.713448108COM58,658$6,561,000thousands by filing date
Honeywell Technologies438516106COM52,363$6,538,000thousands by filing date
Coca-Cola Company191216100COM146,087$6,199,000thousands by filing date
SELECT SECTOR SPDR TR81369Y407SBI CONS DISCR66,260$5,827,000thousands by filing date
VANECK ETF TRUST92189F726BIOTECH ETF48,723$5,800,000thousands by filing date
NESTLE SA ADR641069406COM73,704$5,667,000thousands by filing date
United Parcel Service,Inc. Class B911312106COM50,383$5,406,000thousands by filing date
Chevron Corporation166764100COM49,422$5,306,000thousands by filing date
SELECT SECTOR SPDR TR81369Y308STATE STREET CON95,223$5,197,000thousands by filing date
Alphabet Inc. Reg. Shares C02079K107COM5,969$4,951,000thousands by filing date
DU PONT E I DE NEMOURS & CO263534109COM61,593$4,947,000thousands by filing date
Microsoft Corp594918104COM74,816$4,927,000thousands by filing date
Union Pacific Corporation907818108COM45,534$4,822,000thousands by filing date
AMERICAN INTL GROUP INC COM NEW026874784Stock76,040$4,747,000thousands by filing date
Starbucks Corporation855244109COM80,135$4,679,000thousands by filing date
CENTERPOINT ENERGY INC15189T107COM167,179$4,609,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464288836U.S. PHARMA ETF29,818$4,500,000thousands by filing date
Bristol-Myers Squibb Company110122108COM82,544$4,488,000thousands by filing date
Technology Select Sector SPDR Fund81369Y803SHS82,102$4,376,000thousands by filing date
Alphabet Inc. Reg. Shares A02079K305COM5,084$4,310,000thousands by filing date
ENTERPRISE PRODS PARTNERS L293792107COM151,185$4,174,000thousands by filing date
MAGELLAN MIDSTREAM PARTNERS, L559080106COM UNIT RP LP53,331$4,101,000thousands by filing date
Stryker Corporation863667101COM28,070$3,695,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard Communication Services ETF92204A884SHS36,611$3,473,000thousands by filing date
CELGENE CORP151020104COM27,854$3,465,000thousands by filing date
Comcast Corp20030N101COM91,439$3,437,000thousands by filing date
GENERAL DYNAMICS CORP COM369550108Stock17,934$3,357,000thousands by filing date
FEDEX CORP COM31428X106Stock17,038$3,325,000thousands by filing date
Schlumberger Limited806857108COM42,380$3,309,000thousands by filing date
Utilities Select Sector SPDR Fund81369Y886SHS63,559$3,261,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464287556ISHARES BIOTECH10,975$3,218,000thousands by filing date
INGERSOLL-RAND PLCG47791101SHS39,273$3,193,000thousands by filing date
SPDR GOLD TR78463V107GOLD SHS26,132$3,102,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464288828US HLTHCR PR ETF22,780$3,054,000thousands by filing date
Duke Energy Corporation26441C204COM37,163$3,047,000thousands by filing date
Merck & Co.,Inc.58933Y105COM47,535$3,020,000thousands by filing date
KIMBERLY-CLARK CORP COM494368103Stock22,936$3,019,000thousands by filing date
Philip Morris International Inc.718172109COM26,134$2,950,000thousands by filing date
DOMINION ENERGY INC COM25746U109Stock37,735$2,927,000thousands by filing date
GENERAL MILLS INC COM370334104Stock49,450$2,918,000thousands by filing date
Energy Select Sector SPDR Fund81369Y506SHS38,433$2,686,000thousands by filing date
CSX Corporation126408103COM54,809$2,551,000thousands by filing date
COLGATE PALMOLIVE CO COM194162103Stock34,060$2,492,000thousands by filing date
Lockheed Martin Corporation539830109COM9,234$2,471,000thousands by filing date
Lowes Companies,Inc.548661107COM29,341$2,412,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464287465MSCI EAFE ETF37,625$2,343,000thousands by filing date
INTERNATIONAL PAPER CO COM460146103Stock44,034$2,236,000thousands by filing date
CONSOLIDATED EDISON INC209115104COM28,723$2,230,000thousands by filing date
SELECT SECTOR SPDR TR81369Y100SBI MATERIALS42,264$2,215,000thousands by filing date
Pfizer Inc.717081103COM61,760$2,112,000thousands by filing date
iShares U.S. Technology ETF464287721SHS15,433$2,086,000thousands by filing date
iShares U.S. Medical Devices ETF464288810SHS13,733$2,079,000thousands by filing date
STATE STREET SPDR NYSE TECHNOLOGY ETF78464A102ETF29,350$2,019,000thousands by filing date
HERSHEY CO COM427866108Stock18,105$1,977,000thousands by filing date
CIGNA CORPORATION125509109COM13,095$1,918,000thousands by filing date
EXCHANGE TRADED CONCEPTS TRU301505707ROBO GLB ETF58,834$1,894,000thousands by filing date
UBS Alerian MLP/ MLPI902641646TR UNIT64,920$1,894,000thousands by filing date
T-Mobile US,Inc.872590104COM28,770$1,858,000thousands by filing date
JP MORGAN CHASE & CO46625H365EXCHANGE TRADED57,100$1,844,000thousands by filing date
PUBLIC SVC ENTERPRISE GROUP COM744573106Stock40,838$1,811,000thousands by filing date
American Express Company025816109COM22,650$1,791,000thousands by filing date
KRAFT HEINZ CO COM500754106Stock19,548$1,775,000thousands by filing date
Walmart Inc.931142103COM24,532$1,768,000thousands by filing date
Citigroup Inc.172967424COM29,540$1,767,000thousands by filing date
iShares U.S. Financials ETF464287788SHS16,650$1,732,000thousands by filing date
Amgen Inc.031162100COM10,474$1,718,000thousands by filing date
SIEMENS A G - ADR826197501COM24,800$1,698,000thousands by filing date
Eli Lilly and Company532457108COM20,071$1,688,000thousands by filing date
SPDR SER TR78464A870S&P BIOTECH24,325$1,686,000thousands by filing date
UnitedHealth Group Inc91324P102COM9,961$1,633,000thousands by filing date
Cisco Systems,Inc.17275R102COM47,741$1,613,000thousands by filing date
AIR PRODS & CHEMS INC009158106COM11,850$1,603,000thousands by filing date
BECTON DICKINSON & CO075887109COM8,613$1,579,000thousands by filing date
AMERICAN ELEC PWR CO INC COM025537101Stock23,226$1,559,000thousands by filing date
Southern Company842587107COM31,295$1,557,000thousands by filing date
CANADIAN PACIFIC RAILWAYS13645T100COM10,035$1,474,000thousands by filing date
LEAR CORP COM NEW521865204Stock10,101$1,430,000thousands by filing date
OSI SYSTEMS INC671044105COM19,290$1,407,000thousands by filing date
MasterCard, Inc57636Q104COM12,376$1,391,000thousands by filing date
VANGUARD HEALTH CARE ETF92204A504ETF10,000$1,378,000thousands by filing date
NORFOLK SOUTHN CORP COM655844108Stock11,970$1,340,000thousands by filing date
WALGREENS BOOTS ALLIANCE INC931427108COM16,000$1,328,000thousands by filing date
RAYTHEON CO755111507COM NEW8,552$1,304,000thousands by filing date
Caterpillar Inc.149123101COM13,877$1,287,000thousands by filing date
Goldman Sachs Group,Inc.38141G104COM5,345$1,227,000thousands by filing date
BAXTER INTL INC071813109COM23,570$1,222,000thousands by filing date
BARD C R INC067383109COM4,891$1,215,000thousands by filing date
ROCKWELL AUTOMATION INC COM773903109Stock7,680$1,195,000thousands by filing date
AFLAC INC COM001055102Stock16,400$1,187,000thousands by filing date
UNILEVER PLC904767704SPON ADR NEW23,963$1,182,000thousands by filing date
Dow Chemical Company260543103COM18,515$1,176,000thousands by filing date
MCKESSON CORP COM58155Q103Stock7,925$1,174,000thousands by filing date
Costco Wholesale Corporation22160K105COM6,771$1,135,000thousands by filing date
Wells Fargo & Company949746101COM20,257$1,127,000thousands by filing date
Salesforce.com, Inc79466L302COM13,200$1,088,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES RUSSELL MID-CAP GROWTH ETF464287481ETF10,386$1,077,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464287234MSCI EMG MKT ETF26,950$1,061,000thousands by filing date
L3 TECHNOLOGIES INC502413107COM6,325$1,045,000thousands by filing date
AMERICAN WTR WKS CO INC NEW COM030420103Stock13,125$1,020,000thousands by filing date
SPDR INDEX SHS FDS78463X103ST STR EUROP ETF31,500$1,012,000thousands by filing date
Abbott Laboratories002824100COM22,242$987,000thousands by filing date
Intel Corp458140100COM26,793$966,000thousands by filing date
KROGER CO COM501044101Stock32,396$955,000thousands by filing date
ALLERGAN PLCG0177J108SHS3,980$950,000thousands by filing date
NORTHROP GRUMMAN CORP COM666807102Stock3,882$923,000thousands by filing date
NOVARTIS AG SPONSORED ADR66987V109ADR12,173$904,000thousands by filing date
NextEra Energy,Inc.65339F101COM6,819$875,000thousands by filing date
XYLEM INC COM98419M100Stock16,945$850,000thousands by filing date
Oracle Corporation68389X105COM18,860$841,000thousands by filing date
CVS Health Corporation126650100COM10,504$824,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard FTSE All-World ex-US ETF922042775SHS17,179$821,000thousands by filing date
EMERSON ELEC CO COM291011104Stock13,655$817,000thousands by filing date
DAVITA INC COM23918K108Stock11,566$786,000thousands by filing date
MCCORMICK & CO INC COM NON VTG579780206Stock8,050$785,000thousands by filing date
CBS CORP NEW124857202CL B11,285$782,000thousands by filing date
LAM RESEARCH CORP512807108COM6,000$770,000thousands by filing date
ALLEGION PLCG0176J109ORD SHS10,091$763,000thousands by filing date
CLOROX CO DEL189054109COM5,648$761,000thousands by filing date
WISDOMTREE U S VALUE ETF97717W547COM10,760$756,000thousands by filing date
ROPER TECHNOLOGIES INC COM776696106Stock3,600$743,000thousands by filing date
AMER STATES WTR CO COM029899101Stock16,750$742,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464287697U.S. UTILITS ETF5,760$739,000thousands by filing date
ConocoPhillips20825C104COM14,290$712,000thousands by filing date
UGI CORP NEW COM902681105Stock14,275$705,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR46429B598MSCI INDIA ETF22,258$700,000thousands by filing date
BCE INC COM NEW05534B760Stock15,531$687,000thousands by filing date
PPG INDS INC COM693506107Stock6,250$656,000thousands by filing date
SHIRE PLC82481R106COMMON STOCK-FO3,763$655,000thousands by filing date
POWERSHARES ETF TRUST73935X393CON STAPLE SEC11,115$655,000thousands by filing date
AbbVie,Inc.00287Y109COM10,001$651,000thousands by filing date
Bank of America Corp060505104COM27,575$650,000thousands by filing date
iShares S&P 500 Value ETF464287408SHS6,250$650,000thousands by filing date
PRUDENTIAL FINL INC COM744320102Stock6,091$649,000thousands by filing date
EDISON INTL COM281020107Stock8,033$639,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464287648RUS 2000 GRW ETF3,949$638,000thousands by filing date
AETNA INC NEW00817Y108COM4,833$616,000thousands by filing date
WHOLE FOODS MKT INC966837106COM20,600$612,000thousands by filing date
VANECK ETF TRUST92189F700AGRIBUSINESS ETF11,300$603,000thousands by filing date
EASTMAN CHEM CO COM277432100Stock7,399$597,000thousands by filing date
Gilead Sciences,Inc.375558103COM8,690$590,000thousands by filing date
Netflix, Inc64110L106COM3,991$589,000thousands by filing date
REYNOLDS AMERICAN INC761713106COMMON STOCK9,249$582,000thousands by filing date
DIAGEO PLC SPON ADR NEW25243Q205ADR4,945$571,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464287838U.S. BAS MTL ETF6,355$566,000thousands by filing date
ROCKWELL COLLINS INC774341101COM5,800$563,000thousands by filing date
WHIRLPOOL CORP COM963320106Stock3,240$555,000thousands by filing date
APACHE CORP037411105COM10,701$549,000thousands by filing date
TRINSEO S AL9340P101SHS7,800$523,000thousands by filing date
POWERSHARES ETF TRUST73935X385ENERGY SEC POR13,358$521,000thousands by filing date
TIME WARNER INC887317303COM NEW5,318$519,000thousands by filing date
ATMOS ENERGY CORP COM049560105Stock6,469$510,000thousands by filing date
ROYAL DUTCH SHELL PLC SPN ADR780259206SPONS ADR A9,506$501,000thousands by filing date
EOG RES INC COM26875P101Stock5,096$497,000thousands by filing date
CANADIANNATLRYCOF136375102STOK6,700$495,000thousands by filing date
DUKE REALTY CORP264411505COM NEW18,801$493,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464287796U.S. ENERGY ETF12,736$490,000thousands by filing date
WESTAR ENERGY INC95709T100COMMON STOCK8,800$477,000thousands by filing date
OCCIDENTAL PETE CORP674599105COM7,459$472,000thousands by filing date
SPDR INDEX SHS FDS78463X202EURO STOXX 5012,850$467,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464288562RESIDENTIAL MULT7,257$458,000thousands by filing date
STANLEY BLACK & DECKER INC COM854502101Stock3,425$455,000thousands by filing date
PPL CORP COM69351T106Stock12,185$455,000thousands by filing date
Automatic Data Processing,Inc.053015103COM4,424$452,000thousands by filing date
Mondelez International,Inc. Class A609207105COM10,495$452,000thousands by filing date
KELLANOVA487836108COM6,100$442,000thousands by filing date
STATE STREET SPDR ETF S&P RETAIL78464A714ETF10,390$438,000thousands by filing date
HALLIBURTON CO COM406216101Stock8,828$434,000thousands by filing date
EDWARDS LIFESCIENCES CORP COM28176E108Stock4,604$433,000thousands by filing date
KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N V NY REGIS SHS NEW500472303ADR12,900$414,000thousands by filing date
iShares Expanded Tech-Software Sector ETF464287515SHS3,220$407,000thousands by filing date
ANADARKO PETROLEUM CORP032511107COM6,540$405,000thousands by filing date
ILLINOIS TOOL WKS INC452308109COM3,050$404,000thousands by filing date
OWENS CORNING NEW690742101COM6,400$392,000thousands by filing date
SIMON PPTY GROUP INC NEW COM828806109REIT2,181$375,000thousands by filing date
BLACK HILLS CORP COM092113109Stock5,650$375,000thousands by filing date
AGNC INVT CORP COM00123Q104REIT18,649$370,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464288257MSCI ACWI ETF5,800$366,000thousands by filing date
CONSTELLATION BRANDS INC CL A21036P108Stock2,240$363,000thousands by filing date
VODAFONE GROUP PLC SPONSORED ADR92857W308ADR13,195$348,000thousands by filing date
MGE ENERGY INC55277P104COM5,325$346,000thousands by filing date
LAUDER ESTEE COS INC CL A518439104Stock4,059$344,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464288737GLB CNSM STP ETF3,465$344,000thousands by filing date
EVERSOURCE ENERGY COM30040W108Stock5,821$342,000thousands by filing date
ACACIA COMMUNICATIONS INC00401C108COM5,600$328,000thousands by filing date
URBAN EDGE PPTYS91704F104COM12,350$324,000thousands by filing date
WEC ENERGY GROUP INC COM92939U106Stock5,292$320,000thousands by filing date
iShares S&P 500 Growth ETF464287309SHS2,399$315,000thousands by filing date
ALLSTATE CORP COM020002101Stock3,847$313,000thousands by filing date
CENTENE CORP DEL COM15135B101Stock4,360$310,000thousands by filing date
SYSCOCORP871829107COM5,950$308,000thousands by filing date
ARMOUR RESIDENTIAL REIT INC042315507COM NEW13,536$307,000thousands by filing date
Medtronic PlcG5960L103COM3,800$306,000thousands by filing date
PG&E CORP COM69331C108Stock4,600$305,000thousands by filing date
PORTLAND GEN ELEC CO736508847COM NEW6,750$299,000thousands by filing date
EXPRESS SCRIPTS HLDG CO30219G108COM4,550$299,000thousands by filing date
HUNTSMAN CORP447011107COM12,000$294,000thousands by filing date
WORTHINGTON ENTERPRISES INC981811102COM6,500$293,000thousands by filing date
FMC CORP COM NEW302491303Stock4,200$292,000thousands by filing date
DTE ENERGY CO COM233331107Stock2,865$292,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard Growth922908736COM2,332$283,000thousands by filing date
CORNING INC219350105COM10,440$281,000thousands by filing date
ENERGY TRANSFER L P29273V100COM UT LTD PTN14,275$281,000thousands by filing date
SEAGATE TECHNOLOGY PLCG7945M107SHS6,125$281,000thousands by filing date
MIDDLESEX WTR CO596680108COM7,600$280,000thousands by filing date
SCANA CORP NEW80589M102COM4,254$278,000thousands by filing date
SMUCKER J M CO832696405COM NEW2,100$275,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464287168COM2,976$271,000thousands by filing date
CALIFORNIA WTR SVC GROUP130788102COM7,550$270,000thousands by filing date
AQUA AMERICA INC03836W103COM8,362$268,000thousands by filing date
HELMERICH & PAYNE INC423452101COM3,900$259,000thousands by filing date
iShares Expanded Tech Sector ETF464287549SHS1,870$258,000thousands by filing date
CARDINAL HEALTH INC14149Y108COM3,168$258,000thousands by filing date
KINDER MORGAN INC DEL COM49456B101Stock11,763$255,000thousands by filing date
ZIMMER BIOMET HOLDINGS INC COM98956P102Stock2,085$254,000thousands by filing date
Chubb LimitedH1467J104COM1,855$252,000thousands by filing date
MID AMERICA APARTMENT COMMUNITIES INC.59522J103Common Stock, par value $0.01 per share2,450$249,000thousands by filing date
Danaher Corporation235851102COM2,900$248,000thousands by filing date
Adobe Inc00724F101COM1,877$244,000thousands by filing date
CMS ENERGY CORP COM125896100Stock5,325$238,000thousands by filing date
Eaton Corp. PlcG29183103COM3,200$237,000thousands by filing date
SOUTH JERSEY INDUSTRIES INC838518108COM6,650$237,000thousands by filing date
GLAXOSMITHKLINE PLC-ADR37733W105SPONSORED ADR5,600$236,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464287192US TRSPRTION1,440$236,000thousands by filing date
ASHLAND INC044186104COM1,900$235,000thousands by filing date
PLAINS ALL AMERN PIPELINE L726503105UNIT LTD PARTN7,362$232,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464288844US OIL EQ&SV ETF5,356$225,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR46429B663CORE HIGH DV ETF2,645$221,000thousands by filing date
REALTY INCOME CORP COM756109104REIT3,675$218,000thousands by filing date
ISHARES TR464287739U.S. REAL ES ETF2,775$217,000thousands by filing date
MIMEDX GROUP INC602496101COM22,700$216,000thousands by filing date
LABORATORY CORP OF AMERICA50540R409COM NEW1,500$215,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard Value ETF922908744SHS2,166$206,000thousands by filing date
Vanguard Dividend Appreciation ETF921908844SHS2,282$205,000thousands by filing date
VWO922042858SHS5,152$204,000thousands by filing date
WASHINGTON TRUST BANCORP940610108COMMON STOCK4,074$200,000thousands by filing date
PREFERRED APT CMNTYS INC74039L103COM13,700$180,000thousands by filing date
CONSULTING GRP CAP MKT HI YLD210474839MF13,339$51,000thousands by filing date
TRANSENTERIX INC89366M201COM NEW35,000$42,000thousands by filing date
WALKER INNOVATION INC COM931661102COM10,000$4,000thousands by filing date
TITAN MEDICAL INC.88830X108COM10,450$2,000thousands by filing date
PREMIER LASER SYS A NXXX740522107cs10,400$0thousands by filing dateValue filed as zero, left out of ratios.
CHINA GOLD CORP COM16938L106COM140,000$0thousands by filing dateValue filed as zero, left out of ratios.
AIRTRONA INTL INC00950T106COM70,000$0thousands by filing dateValue filed as zero, left out of ratios.

Amendment chain

FilingRoleFiledAcceptedIngested
13F-HR 0001056515-17-000004this filing2017-04-11acceptance time not in the bulk data set