Skip to content

13F-HR filed by PATTEN & PATTEN INC/TN

PATTEN & PATTEN INC/TN filed this 13F-HR for the quarter ended 2023-12-31, filed 2024-01-23, with 286 holding rows worth $1,217,958,744.

Accession
0001044905-24-000001
Filed
2024-01-23
Accepted by EDGAR
acceptance time not in the bulk data set
Ingested
Source
SEC quarterly data set

Original filing

13F report for Q4 2023

A holdings report, 286 entries on the cover page, a total value of $1,217,958,744 stated on the cover page (in dollars after the unit check, H1), rows summing to $1,217,958,744 with VALUE read as dollars as filed, 13F file number 028-06515. The quarter's positions are built on this report. The resolved quarter.

The information table after summing rows of one CUSIP and put or call (H4), with the CUSIP and issuer name as filed. Values in dollars after the unit check (method).

Issuer as filedCUSIPClassAmountValueValue read asType
Apple Inc037833100COM764,779$147,242,903dollars as filed
Microsoft Corp594918104COM152,932$57,508,406dollars as filed
Alphabet Inc. Reg. Shares A02079K305COM216,366$30,224,167dollars as filed
AbbVie,Inc.00287Y109COM194,533$30,146,779dollars as filed
iShares Global Tech ETF464287291SHS441,953$30,132,356dollars as filed
WESTROCK CO96145D105COM704,321$29,243,408dollars as filed
Visa Inc92826C839COM109,480$28,503,228dollars as filed
ConocoPhillips20825C104COM220,377$25,579,208dollars as filed
Progressive Corporation743315103COM154,906$24,673,428dollars as filed
JPMorgan Chase & Co46625H100COM137,703$23,423,253dollars as filed
UnitedHealth Group Inc91324P102COM39,253$20,665,514dollars as filed
JPMORGAN EQUITY PREMIUM INCOME ETF46641Q332ETF374,594$20,595,199dollars as filed
Costco Wholesale Corporation22160K105COM28,114$18,557,660dollars as filed
Abbott Laboratories002824100COM167,178$18,401,289dollars as filed
SMITH A O CORP COM831865209Stock207,272$17,087,504dollars as filed
Adobe Inc00724F101COM28,249$16,853,353dollars as filed
TRACTOR SUPPLY CO COM892356106Stock77,061$16,570,427dollars as filed
Johnson & Johnson478160104COM101,847$15,963,521dollars as filed
LOUISIANA PAC CORP COM546347105Stock222,805$15,781,278dollars as filed
Merck & Co.,Inc.58933Y105COM129,196$14,084,972dollars as filed
TJX Companies Inc872540109COM147,062$13,795,886dollars as filed
Raytheon Technologies Corporation75513E101COM159,129$13,389,119dollars as filed
Alphabet Inc. Reg. Shares C02079K107COM87,961$12,396,346dollars as filed
EDWARDS LIFESCIENCES CORP COM28176E108Stock162,427$12,385,059dollars as filed
Intuit Inc.461202103COM19,652$12,283,090dollars as filed
SPY78462F103SHS25,406$12,075,845dollars as filed
Walmart Inc.931142103COM74,530$11,749,606dollars as filed
PULTE GROUP INC COM745867101Stock113,660$11,731,985dollars as filed
Qualcomm Incorporated747525103COM80,622$11,660,331dollars as filed
NextEra Energy,Inc.65339F101COM187,730$11,402,720dollars as filed
CANADIANNATLRYCOF136375102STOK86,650$10,885,839dollars as filed
LINCOLN ELEC HLDGS INC533900106COM49,330$10,727,302dollars as filed
iShares U.S. Financials ETF464287788SHS124,802$10,659,339dollars as filed
Cisco Systems,Inc.17275R102COM208,551$10,536,019dollars as filed
Coca-Cola Company191216100COM173,462$10,222,132dollars as filed
Texas Instruments Incorporated882508104COM58,125$9,907,941dollars as filed
PepsiCo,Inc.713448108COM56,400$9,578,948dollars as filed
CONSTELLATION BRANDS INC CL A21036P108Stock38,685$9,352,099dollars as filed
Home Depot, Inc437076102COM26,507$9,185,917dollars as filed
EXXON MOBIL CORP30231G102COM91,169$9,115,103dollars as filed
Eli Lilly and Company532457108COM15,635$9,114,234dollars as filed
Chevron Corporation166764100COM60,093$8,963,469dollars as filed
Advanced Micro Devices,Inc.007903107COM60,436$8,908,871dollars as filed
Honeywell Technologies438516106COM38,746$8,125,424dollars as filed
PAYPALHLDGSINC70450Y103STOK126,909$7,793,482dollars as filed
NIKE,Inc. Class B654106103COM69,195$7,512,501dollars as filed
INGEVITY CORP COM45688C107Stock158,819$7,499,432dollars as filed
HILTON WORLDWIDE HLDGS INC COM43300A203Stock39,588$7,208,579dollars as filed
WEYERHAEUSER CO COM NEW962166104REIT199,310$6,930,009dollars as filed
Duke Energy Corporation26441C204COM70,515$6,842,794dollars as filed
Vanguard S&P 500 ETF922908363COM14,090$6,154,550dollars as filed
OREILLY AUTOMOTIVE INC COM67103H107Stock6,225$5,914,248dollars as filed
DEXCOM INC COM252131107Stock46,122$5,723,279dollars as filed
Intel Corp458140100COM112,756$5,666,004dollars as filed
Lowes Companies,Inc.548661107COM25,200$5,608,265dollars as filed
TRUIST FINL CORP COM89832Q109Stock150,224$5,546,262dollars as filed
LULULEMON ATHLETICA INC550021109COM10,617$5,428,366dollars as filed
FREEPORT MCMORAN INC CL B35671D857Stock125,602$5,346,877dollars as filed
Comcast Corp20030N101COM121,375$5,322,289dollars as filed
Health Care Select Sector SPDR Fund81369Y209SHS37,315$5,089,078dollars as filed
Amazon.com, Inc023135106COM30,972$4,705,886dollars as filed
NORFOLK SOUTHN CORP COM655844108Stock19,538$4,618,397dollars as filed
J P MORGAN EXCHANGE TRADED F46654Q724HEDGED EQUITY LA83,930$4,438,218dollars as filed
MOBILEYE GLOBAL INC60741F104COMMON CLASS A101,655$4,403,695dollars as filed
DIGITAL RLTY TR INC COM253868103REIT32,663$4,395,787dollars as filed
Bristol-Myers Squibb Company110122108COM84,710$4,346,458dollars as filed
Procter & Gamble Co742718109COM29,365$4,303,075dollars as filed
Bank of America Corp060505104COM117,313$3,949,913dollars as filed
HCA Healthcare Inc40412C101COM14,446$3,910,166dollars as filed
PLANET FITNESS MASTER ISSUER L CL A72703H101Stock53,256$3,887,688dollars as filed
NOVARTIS AG SPONSORED ADR66987V109ADR35,600$3,594,532dollars as filed
Prologis,Inc.74340W103COM25,719$3,428,343dollars as filed
Morgan Stanley617446448COM36,733$3,425,352dollars as filed
Citigroup Inc.172967424COM65,944$3,392,157dollars as filed
ECOLAB INC COM278865100Stock16,715$3,315,420dollars as filed
Technology Select Sector SPDR Fund81369Y803SHS16,628$3,200,498dollars as filed
ZOETIS INC CL A98978V103Stock15,998$3,157,525dollars as filed
MasterCard, Inc57636Q104COM7,122$3,037,571dollars as filed
ULTA BEAUTY INC COM90384S303Stock6,173$3,024,708dollars as filed
McDonalds Corporation580135101COM10,184$3,019,602dollars as filed
Boeing Company097023105COM11,546$3,009,657dollars as filed
ISHARES TR464287101S&P 100 ETF13,377$2,988,288dollars as filed
AMERICAN WTR WKS CO INC NEW COM030420103Stock22,575$2,979,674dollars as filed
DOLBY LABORATORIES INC COM CL A25659T107Stock33,790$2,912,022dollars as filed
PHILLIPS 66 COM718546104Stock19,959$2,657,303dollars as filed
DELTA AIR LINES INC COM NEW247361702Stock64,700$2,602,885dollars as filed
FEDEX CORP COM31428X106Stock10,203$2,581,053dollars as filed
3M CO COM88579Y101Stock23,526$2,571,862dollars as filed
SPDR SERIES TRUST78464A698ST STR SP REGBNK48,560$2,546,026dollars as filed
Charles Schwab Corp808513105COM36,660$2,522,208dollars as filed
PINNACLE FINANCIAL PARTNERS IN72346Q104COM28,030$2,444,777dollars as filed
Pfizer Inc.717081103COM84,355$2,428,588dollars as filed
PIONEER NATURAL RESOURCES CO723787107COM10,371$2,332,230dollars as filed
iShares Russell 2000 ETF464287655SHS11,430$2,294,204dollars as filed
Verizon Communications Inc92343V104COM60,551$2,282,767dollars as filed
Broadcom Inc.11135F101COM2,026$2,261,522dollars as filed
Walt Disney Co254687106COM24,704$2,230,499dollars as filed
SELECT SECTOR SPDR TR81369Y704INDL19,337$2,204,225dollars as filed
INVESCO EXCHANGE-TRADED FD TR S&P 500 EQUAL WEIGHT ETF46137V357COM13,505$2,131,043dollars as filed
American Tower Corporation03027X100COM9,777$2,110,745dollars as filed
NVIDIA Corp67066G104COM4,203$2,081,411dollars as filed
XYLEM INC COM98419M100Stock18,090$2,068,772dollars as filed
BECTON DICKINSON & CO075887109COM8,298$2,023,301dollars as filed
REPUBLIC SVCS INC COM760759100Stock12,224$2,015,860dollars as filed
Eaton Corp. PlcG29183103COM8,277$1,993,267dollars as filed
VULCAN MATLS CO COM929160109Stock8,719$1,979,300dollars as filed
Linde plcG54950103COM4,670$1,918,016dollars as filed
GENERAC HLDGS INC368736104COM14,562$1,881,993dollars as filed
ISHARES TR CORE S&P 500 ETF464287200SHS3,848$1,837,874dollars as filed
Applied Materials,Inc.038222105COM11,228$1,819,699dollars as filed
ISHARES TR464287234MSCI EMG MKT ETF44,995$1,809,249dollars as filed
INVESCO QQQ TR46090E103COM4,399$1,801,478dollars as filed
Utilities Select Sector SPDR Fund81369Y886SHS28,031$1,775,201dollars as filed
KIMBERLY-CLARK CORP COM494368103Stock14,439$1,754,477dollars as filed
Communication Services Select Sector SPDR Fund81369Y852SHS22,885$1,662,824dollars as filed
Berkshire Hathaway Inc084670702COM4,575$1,631,719dollars as filed
General Electric Company369604301COM12,708$1,621,923dollars as filed
PRUDENTIAL FINL INC COM744320102Stock15,550$1,612,690dollars as filed
Union Pacific Corporation907818108COM6,487$1,593,387dollars as filed
Energy Select Sector SPDR Fund81369Y506SHS18,537$1,554,142dollars as filed
GENERAL MTRS CO COM37045V100Stock43,257$1,553,791dollars as filed
Vanguard Growth922908736COM4,882$1,517,719dollars as filed
NORTHROP GRUMMAN CORP COM666807102Stock3,231$1,512,560dollars as filed
EXACT SCIENCES CORP COM30063P105Stock20,165$1,491,807dollars as filed
REGIONS FINANCIAL CORP NEW COM7591EP100Stock75,535$1,463,868dollars as filed
DOW HLDGS INC COM260557103Stock26,677$1,462,987dollars as filed
ALPS ETF TR00162Q452ALERIAN MLP34,372$1,461,497dollars as filed
Southern Company842587107COM20,736$1,454,004dollars as filed
VANECK ETF TRUST92189F676COM8,308$1,452,820dollars as filed
KROGER CO COM501044101Stock31,603$1,444,573dollars as filed
ISHARES TR464287770U.S. FIN SVC ETF7,927$1,420,598dollars as filed
MARRIOTT INTL INC NEW CL A571903202Stock6,281$1,416,428dollars as filed
Automatic Data Processing,Inc.053015103COM5,894$1,373,125dollars as filed
Goldman Sachs Group,Inc.38141G104COM3,540$1,365,761dollars as filed
TARGET CORP COM87612E106Stock9,243$1,316,388dollars as filed
HOLOGIC INC436440101COM17,898$1,278,812dollars as filed
Caterpillar Inc.149123101COM4,310$1,274,237dollars as filed
iShares U.S. Technology ETF464287721SHS10,330$1,268,007dollars as filed
American Express Company025816109COM6,543$1,225,753dollars as filed
ASHLAND INC044186104COM14,428$1,216,425dollars as filed
INVESCO EXCH TRADED FD TR II46138E362S&P500 HDL VOL27,475$1,165,215dollars as filed
Tesla Motors, Inc88160R101COM4,601$1,143,256dollars as filed
CARRIER GLOBAL CORPORATION COM14448C104Stock18,724$1,075,694dollars as filed
WALGREENS BOOTS ALLIANCE INC931427108COM40,970$1,069,730dollars as filed
ISHARES TR464288836U.S. PHARMA ETF5,749$1,065,876dollars as filed
Lockheed Martin Corporation539830109COM2,272$1,029,631dollars as filed
Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund81369Y605SHS26,776$1,006,767dollars as filed
International Business Machines Corporation459200101COM6,104$998,245dollars as filed
EMERSON ELEC CO COM291011104Stock10,157$988,570dollars as filed
ISHARES TR46429B663CORE HIGH DV ETF9,547$973,678dollars as filed
T-Mobile US,Inc.872590104COM6,021$965,347dollars as filed
Deere & Company244199105COM2,383$952,890dollars as filed
ELECTRONIC ARTS INC COM285512109Stock6,825$933,728dollars as filed
DOCUSIGN INC COM256163106Stock15,606$927,777dollars as filed
ISHARES TR464287168COM7,818$916,460dollars as filed
Vanguard Dividend Appreciation ETF921908844SHS5,202$886,363dollars as filed
MODERNA INC60770K107COM8,823$877,447dollars as filed
INVESCO EXCH TRADED FD TR II46138E354S&P500 LOW VOL13,903$871,164dollars as filed
Amgen Inc.031162100COM2,968$854,968dollars as filed
Netflix, Inc64110L106COM1,749$851,553dollars as filed
Oracle Corporation68389X105COM7,922$835,267dollars as filed
SCHD808524797COM10,893$829,267dollars as filed
SPDR GOLD TR78463V107GOLD SHS4,296$821,266dollars as filed
NESTLE SA ADR641069406COM7,051$815,307dollars as filed
META PLATFORMS INC CL A30303M102COM2,175$769,863dollars as filed
Philip Morris International Inc.718172109COM7,966$749,479dollars as filed
VWO922042858SHS18,123$744,858dollars as filed
GENERAL MILLS INC COM370334104Stock11,246$732,571dollars as filed
CVS Health Corporation126650100COM9,044$714,114dollars as filed
MASCO CORP574599106COM10,449$699,874dollars as filed
IJH464287507COM2,498$692,296dollars as filed
AIR PRODS & CHEMS INC009158106COM2,476$677,929dollars as filed
COSTAR GROUP INC COM22160N109Stock7,726$675,175dollars as filed
Vanguard Energy ETF92204A306SHS5,748$674,125dollars as filed
COLGATE PALMOLIVE CO COM194162103Stock8,324$663,490dollars as filed
Mondelez International,Inc. Class A609207105COM9,015$652,947dollars as filed
VGT92204A702SHS1,330$643,720dollars as filed
ROYAL BK CDA COM780087102Stock6,330$640,153dollars as filed
Medtronic PlcG5960L103COM7,423$611,507dollars as filed
SEI INVTS CO COM784117103Stock9,500$603,725dollars as filed
SPDR SER TR78464A870S&P BIOTECH6,710$599,136dollars as filed
Starbucks Corporation855244109COM6,130$588,541dollars as filed
ISHARES TR464287580US CONSUM DISCRE7,712$584,338dollars as filed
ISHARES TR464288448INTL SEL DIV ETF20,710$579,673dollars as filed
MOHAWK INDS INC608190104COM5,560$575,460dollars as filed
Altria Group Inc02209S103COM14,069$567,532dollars as filed
Schwab U.S. Small-Cap ETF808524607SHS11,900$562,177dollars as filed
UNUM GROUP COM91529Y106Stock12,211$552,182dollars as filed
BP PLC SPONSORED ADR055622104ADR15,414$545,639dollars as filed
1/100 Berkshire Hath A084990175BRKA100$542,625dollars as filed
ROCHE HLDG LTD SPONS ADR (ISIN #US7711951043 SEDOL #B014J8)771195104ADR14,399$521,676dollars as filed
WILLIAMS SONOMA INC COM969904101Stock2,507$505,961dollars as filed
TEXAS882610108COMMON STOCK320$503,092dollars as filed
DOLLAR GEN CORP COM256677105Stock3,697$502,621dollars as filed
IMPERIAL OIL LTD COM NEW453038408Stock8,750$500,412dollars as filed
DOMINION ENERGY INC COM25746U109Stock10,521$494,487dollars as filed
ENTERPRISE PRODS PARTNERS L293792107COM18,713$493,086dollars as filed
Straumann Holding AG013293546COM3,000$487,932dollars as filed
Schwab U.S. Large-Cap ETF808524201SHS8,592$484,589dollars as filed
VTI922908769COM1,955$463,820dollars as filed
United Parcel Service,Inc. Class B911312106COM2,949$463,692dollars as filed
ISHARESRUSSELL1000GROWTHETF464287614STOK1,509$457,484dollars as filed
PAYCHEX INC704326107COM3,840$457,382dollars as filed
DOVER CORP COM260003108Stock2,954$454,355dollars as filed
CORNING INC219350105COM14,708$447,859dollars as filed
ISHARES CORE S&P U.S. GROWTH ETF464287671ETF4,164$433,472dollars as filed
VANGUARD HEALTH CARE ETF92204A504ETF1,721$431,331dollars as filed
ENBRIDGE INC COM29250N105Stock11,712$421,866dollars as filed
SHELL PLC SPON ADS780259305ADR6,398$420,988dollars as filed
ROYAL CARIBBEAN GROUP COMV7780T103Stock3,230$418,253dollars as filed
AFLAC INC COM001055102Stock5,015$413,737dollars as filed
GENERAL DYNAMICS CORP COM369550108Stock1,593$413,654dollars as filed
ISHARES TR464288778US REGNL BKS ETF9,885$413,588dollars as filed
CROWN CASTLE INC COM22822V101REIT3,584$412,795dollars as filed
REGENERON PHARMACEUTICALS COM75886F107Stock466$409,283dollars as filed
AMERICAN INTL GROUP INC COM NEW026874784Stock6,038$409,074dollars as filed
SCHWAB STRATEGIC TR808524771FUNDAMENTAL US L6,469$400,690dollars as filed
NUCOR CORP COM670346105Stock2,296$399,596dollars as filed
GE HEALTHCARE TECHNOLOGIES INC COMMON STOCK36266G107Stock5,095$393,945dollars as filed
ISHARES TR464287630RUS 2000 VAL ETF2,460$382,112dollars as filed
Micron Technology,Inc.595112103COM4,413$376,605dollars as filed
XPO INC COM983793100Stock4,100$359,119dollars as filed
iShares Gold Trust464285204COM9,079$354,353dollars as filed
ISHARES TR464287192US TRSPRTION1,350$354,280dollars as filed
WILLIAMS COS INC COM969457100Stock10,165$354,047dollars as filed
OTIS WORLDWIDE CORP COM68902V107Stock3,843$343,833dollars as filed
BLACKSTONE INC09260D107COM2,609$341,568dollars as filed
PARK HOTELS & RESORTS INC COM700517105REIT22,025$336,982dollars as filed
iShares U.S. Medical Devices ETF464288810SHS5,980$322,741dollars as filed
iShares Core S&P Small-Cap ETF464287804SHS2,949$319,191dollars as filed
S&P Global,Inc.78409V104COM724$318,936dollars as filed
Analog Devices,Inc.032654105COM1,597$317,100dollars as filed
KINDER MORGAN INC DEL COM49456B101Stock17,804$314,063dollars as filed
STATE STR SPDR DOW JONES IND78467X109UT SER 1831$313,179dollars as filed
SPDR S&P Dividend ETF78464A763SHS2,484$310,419dollars as filed
Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc.883556102COM579$307,327dollars as filed
SCHWAB STRATEGIC TR808524805INTL EQTY ETF8,110$299,762dollars as filed
SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 Growth ETF78464A409SHS4,494$292,380dollars as filed
DELL TECHNOLOGIES INC CL C24703L202Stock3,813$291,694dollars as filed
PPG INDS INC COM693506107Stock1,910$285,640dollars as filed
iShares U.S. Aerospace & Defense ETF464288760SHS2,246$284,344dollars as filed
Wells Fargo & Company949746101COM5,689$280,013dollars as filed
HEWLETT PACKARD ENTERPRISE CO COM42824C109Stock16,173$274,622dollars as filed
iShares Core S&P U.S. Value ETF464287663SHS3,195$269,434dollars as filed
RESMED INC COM761152107Stock1,517$260,954dollars as filed
DUPONT DE NEMOURS INC COM26614N102Stock3,384$260,356dollars as filed
SEMPRA COM816851109Stock3,452$258,000dollars as filed
SANOFI SA SPONSORED ADR80105N105ADR5,100$253,623dollars as filed
iShares MSCI USA Min Vol Factor ETF46429B697SHS3,220$251,257dollars as filed
CSX Corporation126408103COM7,060$244,774dollars as filed
ATMOS ENERGY CORP COM049560105Stock2,102$243,651dollars as filed
CACI INTL INC CL A127190304Stock750$242,895dollars as filed
Vanguard Real Estate922908553SHS2,741$242,195dollars as filed
ISHARES TR464287762US HLTHCARE ETF840$240,334dollars as filed
VANECK ETF TRUST92189H607OIL SERVICES ETF770$238,330dollars as filed
AT&T Inc00206R102COM14,199$238,254dollars as filed
AXONENTERPRISEINC05464C101STOK915$236,372dollars as filed
iShares Core MSCI EAFE ETF46432F842SHS3,336$234,657dollars as filed
SPDR S&P Midcap 400595635103COM455$230,858dollars as filed
BANK MONTREAL MEDIUM COM063671101Stock2,328$230,332dollars as filed
Schwab U.S. Broad Market ETF808524102SHS4,129$229,848dollars as filed
VALERO ENERGY CORP COM91913Y100Stock1,753$227,933dollars as filed
GRAFTECH INTL LTD384313508COM103,270$226,161dollars as filed
Vanguard Mid-Cap Value ETF922908512SHS1,535$222,590dollars as filed
ISHARES RUSSELL 1000 VALUE ETF464287598ETF1,341$221,603dollars as filed
WARNER BROS DISCOVERY INC COM SER A934423104Stock19,455$221,398dollars as filed
RIO TINTO PLC SPONSORED ADR767204100ADR2,938$218,763dollars as filed
CABOT CORP127055101COM2,580$215,430dollars as filed
ISHARES TR464287523COM370$213,157dollars as filed
Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF921946406SHS1,892$211,203dollars as filed
VANGUARD WORLD FD92204A603INDUSTRIAL ETF955$210,511dollars as filed
SANDOZ GROUP AG SPONSORED ADR799926100COM6,527$208,929dollars as filed
iShares S&P 500 Growth ETF464287309SHS2,782$208,928dollars as filed
iShares S&P 500 Value ETF464287408SHS1,200$208,668dollars as filed
YUM BRANDS INC COM988498101Stock1,592$208,011dollars as filed
INVESCO EXCHANGE TRADED FD T46137V142WATER RES ETF3,390$206,315dollars as filed
COCA COLA CONS INC191098102COM221$204,885dollars as filed
BLACKROCK INC CL A COM09247X101COM252$204,574dollars as filed
TRAVELERS COMPANIES INC COM89417E109Stock1,062$202,355dollars as filed
HUNTINGTON BANCSHARES INC COM446150104Stock12,089$153,772dollars as filed
CIM REAL ESTATE FINANCE TRUST12558q103COM15,457$97,531dollars as filed
Nuvista Energy Ltd.67072q104COM10,000$83,327dollars as filed
NOKIA CORP654902204SPONSORED ADR13,250$45,315dollars as filed
DIXIE GROUP INC255519100COMMON STOCK33,300$24,792dollars as filed
AMERICAN LITHIUM CORP COM027259209COM10,715$11,786dollars as filed
TILT HLDGS INC F88688R104COM10,795$254dollars as filed

Amendment chain

FilingRoleFiledAcceptedIngested
13F-HR 0001044905-24-000001this filing2024-01-23acceptance time not in the bulk data set